Choosing Elton John’s all-time greatest albums is a difficult task given his remarkable career spanning numerous decades. Since his discography is so diverse, the decision is really a matter of taste. But within his extensive discography, three albums stand out in particular, demonstrating the breadth, complexity, and timeless appeal of his work. These recordings continue to be legendary well into the new millennium, demonstrating the enduring quality of Elton John’s talent.
Goodbye Yellow Brick Road – 1973
“Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” represents a pinnacle moment in Elton John’s career. Released in 1973, this album encapsulates the essence of John at his most popular, elevating him to the status of a household name. The album is a musical treasure trove, featuring some of John’s most enduring hits, such as “Bennie And The Jets,” “Candle In The Wind,” “Saturday Night’s Alright for Fighting,” and the eponymous “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road.”
Despite its commercial appeal, “Goodbye Yellow Brick Road” ventured into bold territory with the inclusion of “All The Girls Love Alice.” The track, which narrates the haunting tale of a teenage lesbian prostitute’s demise, highlighted John’s willingness to explore controversial themes. Its success and critical acclaim underscore the album’s significance in John’s discography, solidifying its status as a top-tier release that continues to resonate with audiences worldwide.
Madman Across The Water – 1971
Elton John’s songwriting partnership with Bernie Taupin has been instrumental in his success, and “Madman Across The Water,” released in 1971, is a testament to their creative synergy. Taupin’s lyrical prowess combined with John’s musical genius yielded an album that ranges from the peculiar to the profound. The opening track, characterized by its progressive rock leanings, is told from the perspective of a psychopath residing in an insane asylum. Meanwhile, “Levon” offers lyrics that defy easy interpretation, weaving intricate narratives that challenge and enchant listeners.
The album’s standout track, “Tiny Dancer,” has transcended its initial release, becoming a karaoke favorite and a beloved classic. Its enduring popularity showcases the album’s lasting impact, affirming “Madman Across The Water” as a cornerstone in John’s expansive catalog.
Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy – 1975
By 1975, Elton John was at the zenith of his career, yet he sought to innovate further with “Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy.” Conceived as a concept album, it delves into the early days of his career, offering fans a deeply personal glimpse into his musical journey and partnership with Taupin. This album stands out not just for its autobiographical nature but also for its artistic integrity; John focused on crafting a cohesive narrative over pursuing radio hits.
Despite its deviation from mainstream appeal, “Captain Fantastic And The Brown Dirt Cowboy” achieved commercial success, with “Someone Saved My Life Tonight” climbing the charts. This track, among others on the album, reflects John’s skill in crafting songs that resonate on a personal level while achieving widespread acclaim.