The 1970s gave us some of the most iconic rock music of all time. From stadium anthems to genre-defining albums, it’s a decade that still leaves a massive impact on music lovers today. But not every band enjoyed universal love.
While legends like Led Zeppelin and The Who dominated the era, a handful of others didn’t fare so well in the court of public opinion. These bands drew as much criticism as they did applause, sometimes earning a reputation as the most disliked acts of the decade.
Whether they were truly bad or just misunderstood, one thing’s for sure: they still get people talking. Let’s dive into the bands that, for whatever reason, couldn’t escape the 70s without stirring up some serious hate.
The Buggles
The Buggles, a British New Wave duo, had a unique vibe. Their name, inspired by Trevor Horn’s glasses, suggested an offbeat charm. Some even called them a generic version of The Beatles.
Their song “Video Killed the Radio Star” became famous as MTV’s first music video on August 1, 1981. Initially rejected by labels, it was saved by Island Records, thanks to Horn’s girlfriend.
The track hit big internationally, but only gained U.S. fame with MTV’s launch. While catchy, their other songs sounded more like arcade game music than rock hits.
Bo Donaldson and the Haywoods
Bo Donaldson and the Haywoods were a UK-based pop group known for their hit “Billy Don’t Be a Hero.” Originally intended to reflect the American Civil War, the song ended up being linked with the Vietnam War due to its 1970s release.
“Billy Don’t Be a Hero” was their sole major hit. Despite the dark theme, the song’s upbeat melody made the serious subject feel oddly lighthearted.
The combination of dark lyrics and a cheerful tune didn’t sit well with everyone, making Bo Donaldson and the Haywoods a band often criticized.
Edison Lighthouse
Edison Lighthouse was an English pop group active from 1969 to 1977. Their name drew inspiration from the historic Eddystone Lighthouse, built over 300 years ago off Plymouth’s coast.
The band is best known for their single “Love Grows,” which marked their peak. After the hit, lead singer Tony Burrows left, but the band continued despite not owning the name.
Even though they are remembered mostly for that one song, Edison Lighthouse still tours today. Perhaps their popularity might grow again, but it remains uncertain.
Genesis
Genesis often divides classic rock fans. Many lists and blogs label their songs as some of the worst, reflecting confusion over their shifting sound.
The band evolved from a progressive rock style in the early years to a more mainstream approach by the late 70s. This change left some critics and listeners puzzled.
Despite their changes, original members like Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins were undeniably talented. Some argue Genesis reached their peak in the mid-80s.
Morris Albert
Morris Albert’s 1975 song “Feelings” is often criticized for its vague lyrics and lack of depth. While it touches on emotions, many listeners have strong negative reactions to it.
Despite some fans, the song became a target for ridicule, and Albert struggled to make a mark in the U.S. music scene. However, he did maintain a loyal fan base in Brazil.
Albert faced further trouble when he was sued in 1988 for allegedly stealing the melody for “Feelings.” The lawsuit was successful, adding to the song’s controversial legacy.
Captain & Tennille
Let’s start with “Muskrat Love”. Remember that tune? It’s hard to forget, even if you’d like to. The song has earned its share of criticism for being quite awful.
Originally titled “Muskrat Candlelight,” the song could have been even more unsettling with names like “Muskrats in the Dark.” Captain & Tennille didn’t write it—they covered a track by Willis Alan Ramsey.
Despite its mixed reception, Captain & Tennille performed it at the White House for Queen Elizabeth in 1976. The duo, married for 40 years, divorced in 2014, parting ways after decades of performing together.
Rupert Holmes
Rupert Holmes is often remembered for his song “Escape (The Piña Colada Song).” Despite its popularity, he wasn’t a fan of piña coladas himself, which adds a quirky twist to his legacy.
The song is a favorite for some, especially while enjoying a beach drink, but many others have a strong dislike for it. What do you think about it?
Beyond this hit, Holmes had limited success in pop music. However, he found acclaim in musical theater, writing the Tony-winning “The Mystery of Edwin Drood,” which won five Tonys, including Best Musical.