Glenn Frey’s favorite Eagles song might surprise you. Known for their hits like “Hotel California” and “Take It Easy,” the Eagles have a lineup of iconic tracks. But Frey’s choice stands out, and not because it’s the most celebrated.
This song wasn’t a chart-topper or a fan favorite, yet it held a special place for Frey. In fact, many fans might not even consider it one of the Eagles’ best. Still, Frey saw something in this track that kept it close to his heart.
It’s always interesting to see what an artist treasures in their own music. Frey’s choice says a lot about his personal connection to the song, even if it didn’t get the recognition other Eagles hits received.
Glenn Frey’s Surprising Pick
In a 2003 interview with The Uncool, Glenn Frey shared his thoughts on the Eagles’ song “One of These Nights.” He revealed how Don Henley’s soulful voice gave the band a new, richer direction, something that thrilled him. Frey even described the album as their most effortless and enjoyable recording experience.
For Frey, “One of These Nights” represented a major turning point. He felt the song captured the band’s growth in the studio and the significant leap in his and Henley’s songwriting. It was a milestone that set the stage for their future success.
When it came to his favorite Eagles song, Frey’s choice wasn’t what fans might expect. Rather than selecting hits like “Hotel California” or “Take It Easy,” Frey would pick “One of These Nights” every time. For him, it was the song that truly defined the Eagles.
Don Henley’s Take on “One of These Nights”
Don Henley also had high praise for “One of These Nights.” He admired the track for its impressive vocal harmony, especially Randy Meisner’s soaring high notes, joking that they were so high, only dogs could hear them. Henley also appreciated the guitar harmonies, which gave the song a horn-like feel.
Unlike Frey, Henley’s appreciation for the song came from its musical craftsmanship. “One of These Nights” is undeniably catchy and brings the Eagles’ signature harmony to the forefront. While it hints at disco, it stays true to the band’s rock roots with a darker, moodier tone.
Despite not being as iconic as “Hotel California,” the song is memorable. It might not be groundbreaking, but it’s one of those tracks that adds a cool vibe when it plays in the background—perfect for a night out.
Where “One of These Nights” Stands Among Eagles Classics
While “One of These Nights” has its charm, it doesn’t quite measure up to the Eagles’ greatest hits. Unlike the uplifting vibe of “Take It Easy” or the cinematic depth of “Hotel California,” this track doesn’t capture the same energy or mystique that defines the band.
Though it’s enjoyable, calling it the Eagles’ best song might be a stretch. You’re far more likely to hear “Witchy Woman” or “Hotel California” on classic rock stations than “One of These Nights.” These more iconic tracks simply resonate deeper with fans and radio audiences.
In the realm of disco-inspired rock, it also doesn’t shine as brightly as other classics. Unlike the Rolling Stones’ “Miss You” or Kiss’ “I Was Made for Lovin’ You,” this song hasn’t gained the same recognition, even if it’s a fun listen.
A Chart-Topping Success
“One of These Nights” became one of the Eagles’ most successful singles, soaring to No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 during its impressive 17-week run. This title track helped propel the One of These Nights album to the top, where it held the No. 1 spot on the Billboard 200 for five weeks out of a lengthy 56-week chart presence.
The album delivered two more hits alongside its title track. “Lyin’ Eyes” climbed to No. 2, staying on the Hot 100 for 14 weeks, while “Take It to the Limit” reached No. 4 and enjoyed an impressive 23-week run. Together, these tracks underscored the album’s impact and longevity.
For Glenn Frey, “One of These Nights” held special significance beyond the charts. While fans may debate the Eagles’ best song, this one remained a standout for him, reflecting his personal connection to the music.